The popularity of lead
-acid batteries: Lead-acid traction batteries are a favorite for light commercial vehicles, golf carts, recreational boats, material handling vehicles such as forklifts, airport ground support equipment (GSE), electric bicycles, and mobility vehicles for people with disabilities. Better alternatives have been sought for twenty years, and now, like waiting for a bus, two arrive together: lithium-ion batteries and supercapacitors, also known as ultracapacitors.
Diverse Benefits.
In reality, these vehicles don't form a coherent group when it comes to their traction energy storage needs. It's true that they all tolerate a limited range. People still buy them even though their range is only 5 to 20 miles. However, the weight of the lead-acid battery in a golf cart, recreational boat, GSE, and other high-mobility vehicles keeps the center of gravity low, preventing tipping over. With land vehicles, the weight can also improve road grip.
When Weight Is a Headache:
In contrast, for electric bikes and small mobility vehicles, which can be stored in a car or at home, weight is, quite literally, a headache. Most electric bikes are bought by people who live in apartments and want to store the bike, or at least the battery, in the apartment overnight to recharge it and prevent theft. Most electric bike designs mount the battery in a raised case or in the middle of the frame, where the weight actually makes them very heavy. A bright spark at a recent British Electric Bike Association meeting in the Houses of Parliament referred to this as “A brick in a butterfly.”
The drawbacks of lead-acid batteries:
The various reasons for wanting to get rid of lead-acid traction batteries include the inconvenience of having three sets for a forklift—one in use, one being recharged, and one cooling down. Then there's the handling of the acid, the short lifespan, the polluting lead—despite the extensive recycling process—and the poor energy and power density, which makes them enormous and wastes valuable vehicle space. Different vehicles exhibit these problems to varying degrees. For example, a mobility aid for people with disabilities can cause a serious crisis if it becomes inoperable due to a power failure or discharge.
Motorcycles need onboard chargers.
Electric motorcycles, including bicycles converted to electric power, partially or fully, and electric scooters where the rider's feet rest on a platform without pedals, require a charger. In these cases, something smaller than a lead-acid battery frees up space and weight for the convenience of an onboard charger, something already taken for granted in all mobility vehicles. An onboard charger reduces range anxiety, as we are much more likely to be able to charge en route and upon arrival at our destination if all that is needed is a domestic power outlet. Furthermore, ground-penetrating electric vehicles (GPEs) are being used extensively these days, often shared among airlines, and the extra power—for example, to pull a wider range of aircraft—and the extra range, expressed as less frequent recharging time (i.e., less downtime) are of interest. Reliability is also becoming increasingly important.
Tolerance for Frequent Stop-Starts
: Many commercial vehicles must tolerate a high rate of stop-start driving. Most conventional cars and commercial vehicles now automatically switch off their engines when they come to a stop for any reason. Some so-called micro-hybrid vehicles are actually electric vehicles where regenerated power briefly drives the wheels, no more so than the battery's starting function. In these vehicles, the lead-acid battery is frequently used, but it struggles with low temperatures and harsh operating cycles.
High Current Tolerance:
Fast charging stations must be connected to more tolerant batteries, or the batteries will be damaged or destroyed by the spark. The new energy harvesting shock absorbers being tested on commercial and military vehicles can also suddenly pump out kilowatts, and lead-acid batteries generally cannot withstand this. There is a shift towards more reliable and economical AC traction motors, and therefore also towards regenerative braking without the need for additional ignition batteries. This paves the way for simple replacement.
Occasional replacement of lead-acid batteries
: Physically, it will be possible to replace lithium-ion batteries in mobility vehicles by simply swapping them out, but these will then be unstable in most cases and may require a longer wheelbase or other stabilization measures. Exceptions will be electric wheelchairs and very lightweight, foldable or detachable 3- and 4-wheeled scooters that fit even in small vehicles. Other vehicles will need to be redesigned, for example, with a wider wheelbase, steel components, or, ironically, lead-acid weighting.
Rapid Adoption of Lithium-Ion Electric Bicycles Outside of China:
The contrast in motorcycles was evident at the BEBA meeting with some twenty electric motorcycles, all customized with lithium-ion batteries. This illustrates how, outside of China's main market, where price and reliability are the dominant criteria, the lithium option is rapidly capturing 100% of the market.
Standardized Replacement:
Lead-acid replacements have indeed arrived. K2 Energy Solutions (K2), a Nevada-based technology company that manufactures and sells rechargeable batteries, packs, and systems, has introduced a new battery that further strengthens its market leadership in the lithium-ion and lithium iron phosphate (LFP) families.
Known as the K2B24V10EB, K2's latest rechargeable LFP battery is a 24V 9.6Ah battery, making it a suitable replacement for lead-acid battery buyers seeking a lighter, stronger, and more robust solution that allows for longer run times. It has been developed for electric wheelchairs, mobility aids, and other applications currently using lead-acid batteries, such as those found in standard motorcycles, some types of cars, or golf carts. Weighing 5.5 pounds (2.5 kg), it is advertised as containing no heavy, expensive, and hazardous metals or chemicals typical of other products, making it a more environmentally friendly battery. Tests show that, when used properly, the batteries recharge faster and last three to five times longer than conventional batteries, retaining their charge even after extended storage.
Supercapacitors:
If the burgeoning lithium-ion scene isn't enough to worry lead-acid battery enthusiasts, they should consider supercapacitors, known as ultracapacitors by those using them in electric bus batteries. Supercapacitors help with the rapid charging and discharging of lithium-ion batteries in particular, but they haven't stored enough energy per unit volume or weight, or even stored it long enough, to impact traction batteries on their own. The only exception has been companies like Sinautec, integrating charging coils every few miles along a bus route so the bus can run on its own using more reliable, longer-lasting supercapacitors. That has never become widespread, at least due to the high cost of road excavation.
However, supercapacitors have been improving rapidly. They tend to be free of toxic materials or materials subject to price increases, such as cobalt in most lithium-ion traction batteries currently in use, and they double the lifespan of lithium-ion batteries and triple the lifespan of lead-acid batteries. Their previously rapid self-discharge and poor energy density have been improved. Many new applications are emerging at every step, such as mobile phone cameras with long-range flash.
Now, lead-acid traction batteries are in the spotlight.
Researchers at the University of Texas at Austin's Cockrell School of Engineering have synthesized a new carbon supercapacitor with a continuous three-dimensional network featuring highly curved, atom-thick walls that primarily form pores 0.6–5 nm wide. Supercapacitor cells built with this material achieve high gravimetric capacitance and energy density values with organic and ionic liquid electrolytes.
This energy density approaches that of lead-acid batteries, while retaining the high-density power delivery characteristic of supercapacitors. The processes are easily scalable to an industrial level in materials science and mechanical engineering, according to Professor Rodney S. Ruoff.
Comprehensive update
The latest developments in supercapacitors, lithium-ion batteries, and lead-acid batteries used in all types of electric vehicles will be covered extensively at the upcoming Electric Vehicles Land Sea Air event in Stuttgart, Germany, on June 28 and 29.
Presentations will be given by leading developers of supercapacitors, also known as asymmetric double-layer electrochemical capacitors that combine the characteristics of lithium-ion and supercapacitors, and by numerous manufacturers of water, land, and air vehicles that employ lead-acid and lithium-ion batteries, as well as various forms of fuel cells, for traction power. The focus is on what comes next, and the event has a global reach.
Author: Dr. Peter Harrop, President, IDTechEx
