Although most switching regulators are not perfect, this trend in core voltages demands a very precise power supply for proper operation.(1) Window voltage monitors help ensure that devices operate at the correct core voltage levels; however, the accuracy of the value or limit is a major factor in maximizing the usable power window.2
This article explains how using a high-precision window voltage monitor maximizes power supply output. By improving the usable power supply window for device core voltages, operation within the valid operating power supply range is ensured.
Introduction
The power consumption of digital circuits is a major concern, as the demand for portable and battery-powered devices is increasing dramatically. Computation and processing are becoming ever more complex, requiring faster devices such as field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) and other processing chips. Complex processes demand more power, which in turn causes the fast chips to overheat. Figure 1 shows that the trend in process technology is shrinking device dimensions to the nanometer range, necessitating a corresponding reduction in operating voltages, optimizing processing speed, and extending device lifespan.3
With this trend toward optimizing technological processes, high-precision power supplies are required. If the actual performance of the power supplies is not taken into account, risks to system performance can arise. Since most regulators are not precise enough, if the core voltage drops below the operating requirements, processing devices (FPGAs, for example) risk failure due to errors. And with continuous operation, if the core voltage exceeds the maximum operating requirement, it can damage the FPGA and cause downtime failures in the logic. All these risks can be caused by load conditions, operating temperature, and aging (1). Although FPGAs are mentioned in most of the examples in this article, the same principle applies to other computing and processing devices.

Figure 1. The supply voltages of integrated circuits decrease with the evolution of the technological process.3
Tolerances
Tolerance requires careful attention when designing and monitoring power supplies for computing and processing chips, as it can be treated differently from each perspective. In this article, we define each tolerance in the following sections.
Core voltage tolerance
The core voltage tolerance corresponds to the power supply specifications of the computing device's core. Table 1 shows the core voltage specifications for the Altera Arria 10 FPGA as an example. The minimum and maximum tolerance range is ±3.3% of the nominal value. Operating this device below the standard minimum or above the maximum will cause performance problems. A tighter tolerance is required for optimal performance and low power consumption.
Table 1. Altera Arria 10 Core Voltage Specification
|
Symbol |
Description |
Condition |
Min |
Typical |
Max |
Unit |
|
VCC |
Core voltage power supply |
Standard power |
0.87 |
0.9 |
0.93 |
V |
|
Low consumption |
0.92 |
0.95 |
0.98 |
V |
Power supply tolerance
Power supply tolerance is the output deviation or output regulation performance of the power supply. Achieving a tight power supply tolerance requires expert design. However, it can change over time due to various external factors, such as component degradation. In the application, this power supply tolerance must be within the core voltage tolerance. Any operation of the power supply output can cause problems for the processing and computing device, such as in FPGAs. A regulator with a stated tolerance may not operate exactly at the center of the output voltage regulation specification, but rather just within the regulation range. This can be due to DC error caused by the standard value of the resistors used in the feedback loop, which has an inherent tolerance, as well as the robustness of the reference voltage and the optimization of the feedback loop compensation. Let's consider, as an example, an FPGA whose core voltage is supplied by a switching regulator. This switching converter, with a declared tolerance of ±2%, can operate anywhere within the 4% window. It may be below the nominal value but still within -2%, thus putting an FPGA at risk of timing problems. Or it may be close to the +2% limit, which may still meet the FPGA requirement but is not optimal and wastes energy. If left unchecked, the device may end up operating outside the recommended voltage levels, which can lead to more serious problems and should be avoided.
Window supervisor tolerance
The window monitor tolerance, or tolerance window, sets the undervoltage (UV) and overvoltage (OV) thresholds as a percentage of the nominal value. For a window voltage monitor with a nominal voltage of 1 V and a tolerance window of ±3%, the UV threshold is set at 1 V × 0.97 and the OV threshold at 1 V × 1.03. However, these thresholds, UV and OV, have their own tolerances known as threshold accuracy.
Use of window voltage monitors
A window voltage monitor ensures that devices operate within their specified voltage range by establishing UV and OV thresholds. It outputs a reset signal if the supply voltage falls outside these limits, helping to prevent system errors and protect electronic devices from potential damage. The timing diagram in Figure 2 shows how a reset output is generated when a monitored voltage falls below the UV threshold or exceeds the OV threshold. Several window voltage monitor architecture options are available for setting the UV and OV thresholds and selecting the operating tolerance for optimal performance.2

Figure 2. Timing diagram showing a reset output in the case of UV and OV.
However, choosing and optimally using a window monitor is not as simple as it seems. The appropriate tolerance window must be carefully selected from a range of available options. Furthermore, the reset limits for UV and OV come with their own accuracy specifications. The threshold accuracy, usually expressed as a percentage, is the degree to which the actual reset threshold matches the calculated or target threshold, which is determined by a resistor divider and a bandgap circuit in the integrated circuit (IC) design (4). The more robust the reference voltage and resistors, the greater the achievable accuracy. Figure 3 illustrates the tolerance window and threshold accuracy of a window voltage monitor. The actual UV and OV thresholds, UV_TH and OV_TH respectively, can vary within the minimum and maximum accuracy specifications.

Figure 3. Variation of the undervoltage and overvoltage limit or threshold with its accuracy specification.
Power supply performance calculations are often performed during system design. For an FPGA core voltage with a ±3% operating tolerance or specification, ±1% can be allocated to the power supply's DC regulation error, ±1% to the output ripple voltage, and another ±1% to the transient response. Using a power supply with a ±2% regulation error will leave less margin for transients. This increases the risk of device malfunction when directly powered, as transients can fall outside the core voltage specification window. Errors can be prevented by using window voltage monitors to safely put the FPGA into reset mode when this occurs.
Choosing the appropriate tolerance window
One of the common difficulties when using a window voltage monitor is setting and selecting the appropriate tolerance window. Users tend to choose a window voltage monitor with the same tolerance as the core voltage requirement. For example, a window voltage monitor with a ±3% tolerance window is used for a core voltage requirement that has a ±3% tolerance. Due to threshold accuracy, choosing the same tolerance as the FPGA's core voltage operating requirement can trigger a reset output anywhere near the maximum overvoltage threshold OV_TH(max) and the minimum undervoltage threshold UV_TH(min), potentially leading to malfunction. In Figure 4a, the monitored power supply could exceed the core voltage tolerance and might not be detected by the monitor at its actual operating threshold if threshold accuracy is not taken into account. This power supply exceeding ±3% will be delivered to a microprocessor core, so a more appropriate tolerance window must be selected. To avoid the risks of such a condition, the OV_TH (max) and UV_TH (min) values must be set within the ±3% core voltage tolerance requirement. However, a portion of the usable power supply window will be "digested" for accuracy, resulting in a reduced power supply operating window, as shown in Figure 4b.

Figure 4. Window stress monitor tolerance setting (a) equal to core stress tolerance and (b) within core stress tolerance.

Figure 5. Permissible power window and reset response (a) with low threshold accuracy and (b) with high threshold accuracy.

Figure 6. Effective operating power supply window with (a) ±1.5% threshold accuracy and (b) ±0.3% threshold accuracy.
The impact of threshold accuracy
Consider two window voltage monitors with different threshold accuracies monitoring the same core voltage supply. The actual UV and OV thresholds of the more accurate monitor deviate less from the expected UV and OV threshold values than those of the less accurate monitor. In Figure 5a, it can be seen that a lower threshold accuracy will provide a narrower supply window, as the reset output signal will be triggered when the core supply voltage is anywhere within the UV and OV monitoring range. In applications with a low-accuracy power supply and poor regulation, this could result in a more sensitive and oscillation-prone system. Meanwhile, a high threshold accuracy provides a wider usable supply window, improving system performance by allowing for more stable operation, as shown in Figure 5b.

Figure 7. Typical application circuit of the MAX16193, the industry's highest threshold accuracy window monitor through core temperature and input/output supply voltage monitoring of an MCU.
Figure 6 illustrates an example of monitoring a 2.5 V core voltage with a tolerance specification of ±5% using two window voltage monitors with different threshold accuracies. The tolerance window used in this example may not be the actual available options, but they were chosen to account for threshold accuracy. The window voltage monitor used has a threshold accuracy of ±1.5% and ±0.3% for Figures 6a and 6b, respectively. When using a threshold accuracy of ±1.5%, the optimal tolerance window to avoid operating in a malfunction region shown in Figure 6a is ±3.5%. This results in a power supply operating window of 100 mV. With a threshold accuracy of ±0.3%, the optimal tolerance window that maximizes the power supply is ±4.7% without risk of malfunction. These adjusted values will give the power supply an operating window of 220 mV. This difference in accuracy more than doubles the power supply's operating window, maximizing its performance.
The calculations above were obtained using the Calculator , a tool that helps you easily understand and visualize the various parameters of a window voltage monitor. It also allows users to check whether the device specifications meet design requirements, such as the power supply's operating window. This tool is available for download on the following product pages: MAX16138, MAX16191, MAX16193, MAX16132/MAX16133/MAX16134/MAX16135, MAX16137.
With the continuous improvement of window voltage monitor architecture and performance to meet ever-lower core voltage demands, threshold accuracies can now range from ±1.5% to ±0.3%. The MAX16193, a dual-channel monitor circuit with ±0.3% accuracy, is the industry's highest threshold voltage monitor across a range of temperatures as of 2024. It features a variety of factory-cut tolerance windows from ±2% to ±5% to accommodate different supply voltages and tolerances for industrial and automotive applications. In the typical application circuit of Figure 7, input channel 1 (IN1) monitors the low voltage rails of the core from a threshold range of 0.6 V to 0.9 V with an accuracy of ±0.3%, while input channel 2 (IN2) monitors the higher rails of the system from a threshold range of 0.9 V to 3.3 V with an accuracy of ±0.3%.
The threshold accuracy specification of the MAX16193 is true for all temperatures within the operating range from -40°C to +125°C. Figures 8a and 8b show that the device's high threshold accuracy for the two inputs IN1 and IN2 holds true at different temperatures. While other voltage monitors perform optimally only within a specific range, this device guarantees high accuracy from the minimum to the maximum operating temperature.

Figure 8. Accuracy graphs of the UV and OV thresholds as a function of temperature for (a) IN1 and (b) IN2.
Conclusion
To keep pace with the demand for speed and power optimization, and in conjunction with advancements in process technology, device core voltages are becoming increasingly lower and tolerances increasingly tighter. Window voltage monitors help prevent serious problems in these devices. However, threshold accuracy plays a crucial role in operation within the device's specification window. The high threshold accuracy of window voltage monitors helps maximize power supply performance by improving the operating power supply window, thereby preventing frequent unwanted restarts and system oscillation.
References
1Nathan Enger. "Caring for and feeding FPGA power supplies: A how-and-why guide to success." Analog Dialogue, vol. 52, no. 11, November 2018.
2Camille Bianca Gómez and Noel Tenorio. "Optimize your system design with the right window voltage monitor." Analog Dialogue, Vol. 58, No. 3, September 2024.
3Mohammed Mahaboob Basha, Kota Venkata Ramanaiah, and Palakolanu Ramana Reddy. "Design of 10T-Full near-threshold subtractor circuit for energy-efficient signal processingapplications ." International Journal of Image Processing, Graphics &
4Noel Tenorio. "How voltage supervisors address power supplynoise and failures ." Analog Dialogue, Vol. 57, No. 4, November 2023.
5 "Voltage Monitors and Supervisors Product Highlights." Analog Devices, Inc.
6 "Keep the Product Working-Microprocessor Supervisors Offer Big Insurance in Small Packages." Analog Devices, Inc., November 2001.
7 Pinkesh Sachdev. " FPGA Power System Management Design Note ". Analog Devices, Inc., March 2020.
8 Caroline Hayes. "Supply Voltage Monitoring Design for Multirail Boards". Electronic Specifier, October 2015.
About the authors
Noel Tenorio is Product Applications Manager for high-performance monitoring and multi-market power management products at Analog Devices Philippines. He joined ADI in August 2016. Prior to ADI, he worked as a design engineer at a switched-mode power supply research and development company for six years. He holds a bachelor's degree in electronic and communications engineering from Batangas State University, a postgraduate degree in electrical engineering with a specialization in power electronics, and a master's degree in electronic engineering from Mapua University. He also played a key role in application support for thermoelectric refrigerator control products before moving into monitoring products.
Camille Bianca Gomez is a Product Applications Engineer at Multimarket Power-East. She joined Analog Devices in March 2022 and holds a degree in Electronic Engineering from Universidad De La Salle-Campus de La Laguna. Previously, she worked as a design engineer at an automotive manufacturing company for three and a half years and now focuses on product development and support.
