Sensing Technologies1There's no doubt that silicon temperature sensors are gaining ground, and there are good reasons for this. They are simple devices that don't require extensive knowledge of thermal design, yet they integrate features that give designers the flexibility to add more functionality to their products. Other reasons include their relatively low price, their small footprint within the overall temperature sensing solution, and their potential to reduce energy consumption compared to other technologies. Furthermore, the fact that this latest generation of silicon sensors achieves significantly higher accuracy than previous generations might tip the scales in favor of using a silicon sensor for the first time. Whatever the reason for considering silicon temperature sensing, it's important to understand the three distinct types of silicon sensors, their logic, voltage, or series outputs, and the advantages each offers for a specific application.
Silicon sensors with voltage output


The operation of a temperature sensor with voltage output is similar to that of a thermistor, which is probably the most widely used device for temperature sensing.


The resistance of a thermistor varies with temperature changes. The resistance of a PTC (positive temperature coefficient) thermistor will increase as the temperature rises, while the resistance of an NTC (negative temperature coefficient) thermistor will decrease as the temperature rises.


A temperature sensor with a voltage output provides an output voltage proportional to the temperature, with a typical temperature coefficient of 6.25 mV/°C, 10 mV/°C, or 19.5 mV/°C. Temperature-to-
voltage converters can detect temperatures from -55°C to +150°C with a temperature offset that allows for reading negative temperatures without requiring a negative supply voltage. Typical operating current values ​​are on the order of tens of microamps, minimizing self-heating and maximizing battery life.


Using a thermistor presents certain drawbacks compared to a silicon temperature sensor with a voltage output. The power consumption of a thermistor-based solution can be several orders of magnitude higher than that of more advanced silicon-based temperature sensors, and thermistors are nonlinear, thus limiting their temperature range. Depending on the application's temperature range, the thermistor-based solution may also require external circuitry, which can add board space and increase the overall cost.
In contrast, silicon-based solutions are highly linear over a temperature range of -55°C to +150°C and are available in SC70 packages. Overall, therefore, silicon can offer a smaller, less expensive, and lower-power solution than a thermistor.


Silicon sensors with logic outputs:
Logic output temperature sensors generally function like a thermostat, notifying the system when a maximum or minimum temperature limit has been reached. Sometimes called temperature switches, they can be used to activate a fan or a warning light when excessively high or low temperatures are detected. Because the output is usually not fixed, the switch can be turned off when the temperature falls below or rises above the set temperature. Logic output sensors typically have built-in hysteresis of a few degrees Celsius to prevent signal bounce at the output.


Sensing Technologies2With a thermistor, one way to implement it is through a comparator circuit. However, this would introduce errors into the system, such as offset and offset drift from the comparator, which would have to be resolved by adjusting the resistor values ​​used in the circuit and with a single temperature adjustment to calibrate the circuit.


A silicon-based solution would be much simpler to implement, as the manufacturer handles all the adjustment and calibration.
Silicon sensors with serial output


The most common way to achieve highly accurate and repeatable temperature measurements has been to use thermocouples or RTDs. However, as Figure 1 shows, both solutions can require the development of large, expensive, and complex circuits to achieve high temperature accuracy or high measurement resolution.


In silicon temperature sensing, serial-output sensors offer the highest accuracy, integration, and flexibility while retaining the inherent simplicity of the silicon solution. Serial-output sensors use two- or three-wire interfaces to connect to the microcontroller and typically incorporate an analog-to-digital converter (ADC) that converts the analog output of the internal sensing element into a digital output. An example of a serial-output temperature sensor is the Microchip MCP9804, shown in Figure 2. This high-accuracy, high-integration digital temperature sensor achieves a typical temperature accuracy of 0.25°C and a user-selectable measurement resolution between 0.5°C and 0.0625°C in a tiny 2 mm x 3 mm DFN package.


Many serial-output temperature sensors also integrate user-programmable functions, such as under- or over-temperature alerts and integrated EEPROM. These features can be used to simplify design, increase flexibility, improve temperature sensing accuracy, and reduce overall system cost.


The most common limitation of serial-output temperature sensors, compared to RTDs and thermocouples, is their operating temperature range. Silicon temperature sensors are generally specified to operate between -55°C and +150°C, while RTDs and thermocouples can provide accurate measurements for a few hundred degrees Celsius or thousands of degrees Celsius, respectively.


Conclusion:
All temperature sensing technologies have advantages and disadvantages, and there is no single technology suitable for all temperature sensing applications.


For applications operating within a limited temperature range, thermistors can provide a low-cost temperature sensing solution. For high accuracy exceeding several hundred degrees Celsius, RTDs may be a suitable solution, but they require careful tuning and calibration and can be more expensive than thermistor- or silicon-based sensor solutions. If extreme temperatures need to be measured, thermocouples are likely the most appropriate solution. However, for the vast majority of applications that do not require measuring a very wide temperature range, silicon-based sensors can significantly simplify design, maintain accuracy, and integrate features that increase system flexibility and performance.

References

- Microchip Technology Application Note AN897, “Thermistor Temperature Sensing with MCP6S2X PGAs,” by Kumen Blake and Steven Bible.
- Microchip Technology Application Note AN895, “Oscillator Circuits for RTD Temperature Sensors,” by Ezana Haile and Jim Lepkowski.
- Microchip Technology Application Note AN1001, “IC Temperature Sensor Accuracy Compensation with a PIC® Microcontroller,” by Ezana Haile.
- Microchip Technology Application Note AN1154, “Precision RTD Instrumentation for Temperature Sensing,” by Ezana Haile.
- Microchip Technology “Temperature Sensor Design Guide,” DS21895C.

Author:

John Austin, Microchip Technology Inc.

More information or a quote